Meandering Through Time
  • Home
  • My Family Stories
    • Bustaine of Braunton: Introduction
    • Hunt of Barnstaple Introduction >
      • Christopher Hunt >
        • Edward Hunt >
          • Richard Hunt >
            • Richard Hunt
            • Mary Hunt
    • Lakeman of Mevagissey >
      • Peter Lakeman c1698-1740
    • Meavy Introduction >
      • 6th to 9th Century Meavy >
        • Meavy Pre Conquest >
          • 1066 and Life in Domesday England >
            • Domesday and 13th Century Charters >
              • The Anarchy >
                • Walter, Wido and William Meavy >
                  • The Beginnings of a New Era
    • Mitchell of Crantock: An Introduction >
      • William Mitchell of Crantock >
        • Samuel Mitchell of Crantock >
          • Edith Mitchell >
            • Epilogue: Lescliston Farm
    • Mohun of Dunster: Introduction >
      • William Mohun c1050 - c1111 >
        • William Mohun c1100 - c1143 >
          • William Mohun - 1176 >
            • William - 1193 >
              • Reynold Mohun c1183 - 1213
              • Reynold Mohun c1210 -1257 >
                • Alice Mohun
    • Purches of Hampshire and Cornwall >
      • Samuel Purches 1733 - 1804 >
        • Samuel Purches 1766 - >
          • William Samuel Purches 1803 - 1861 >
            • Henry James Purches
    • Scoboryo of St Columb Major >
      • James and Joan Scoboryo 1640 - 1686
    • Thomas Vaughan: An Introduction >
      • Chapter One: Monmouthshire, Wales.
      • Chapter Two: The Beaufort Patronage
      • ​Chapter Three: Out With the Old
      • Chapter Four: Kentish Connections and Opportunities >
        • Chapter Five: Getting Personal
        • Chapter Six: ​The Children of Thomas Vaughan
        • Chapter Seven: Moving on
        • ​Chapter Eight: At Ludlow
        • Chapter Nine: The Arrest
        • Chapter Ten: Three Castles
        • Chapter Eleven: The Beginning of the End
        • Chapter Twelve: A Death Deserved ?
    • Smith of Barkby Introduction >
      • Susanna Smith
    • Taylor Introduction >
      • Joseph Taylor >
        • John Henry Taylor
    • Tosny of Normandy >
      • Godehute de Tosny
    • Toon of Leicestershire: Introduction >
      • John Toon 1799 -
      • Thomas Toon 1827 - 1874
    • Underwood of Coleorton Introduction
  • Other Families
  • History Blog
  • Wars of the Roses Blog
  • The Ancestors
  • A to E
  • F to J
  • K to O
  • P to T
  • U to Z
  • Hendley of Coursehorne Kent
    • 5th to 12th Century Hendleys >
      • Gervais Hendley 1302 - c1344 >
        • Thomas Hendley >
          • Grevais Hendley c 1471 - 1534 >
            • Walter Hendley >
              • Elizabeth Hendley >
                • Ellen Hendley 1521- 1560 >
                  • Anne Hendley 1523 - >
                    • Other Hendleys
  • Pigott Family of Whaddon Buckinghamshire
  • Links
  • Contact

1478: The Trial and Execution of George Duke of Clarence.

16/4/2016

0 Comments

 
The 18th of February 1478 saw the death of George, Duke of Clarence, brother to both Edward IV and Richard III. 

George was one of the sons of Richard, Duke of York and Cecily Neville, he has been described as misunderstood and ambitious, Shakespeare calls him
'False, Fleeting, Perjur'd Clarence." ​
Picture
Whatever he was, his death was the result a number of bad decisions that were to be his undoing, they are included in a long list of facts that give us some insight into George's life. There isn't much written about Clarence as a person at all, so a couple of decent *biographies are needed to give us a balanced look at Clarence's life. Because there are nothing other than facts, Clarence's character is hard to define.

 In some ways, I do feel sorry for him, and I have often wondered if we could apply the modern term 'middle child syndrome' to help understand his personality. Maybe it was his position within his family that made him the man he was, looking at the personality traits of a modern 'middle child' surprisingly Clarence fits the 'profile' on a number of points. 

1. Middle children are not particularly interested in family hierarchy or ranking:

Clarence could not have cared less that his brother was king, he would undermine him given an opportunity, he had joined in all the careless talk, calling into question the legitimacy of the king's birth. His later actions convinced Edward that he was looking to take the throne out from under him.

2. Middle children are more interested in taking advice from others outside the main family group:

Clarence was reliant on his cousin Richard Neville rather than Edward or Richard. He took Neville's 'advice' on more than one occasion, joining him in supporting a northern rebellion and went along with the idea to restore King Henry VI to the throne of England, realising too late that listening to Neville was not a good idea after all.

3. Middle children are risk-takers and are more rebellious than their siblings:

Clarence certainly ticks both of these boxes. By rebelling with Neville, Clarence risked everything and lost. He lost his position as Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, and by organising yet another rebellion, because of the loss of his Warwick lands to Richard, he caused a major rift that was ultimately the last nail in his coffin.

4. Middle children don't like conflict:

This is one category that Clarence doesn't fit into.

Of course, Clarence wasn't a middle child at all, he was number six of seven so you could argue that this hypothesis doesn't make any sense at all, but it does if you look at it from the point of view that he was eventually slap bang in the middle of three boys. His older brother Edmund had died at the Battle of Wakefield aged just seventeen, I wonder if he had lived, he would have shown the same personality traits as Clarence, or would Clarence have been a different person altogether? 

Supposition this maybe, but whatever the cause Clarence turned out to be a weak self-centred man, and in the end, it was greed and jealousy that cost him his life. 

So, what was going on within the royal family, the royal court and the country as a whole that caused a brother of two kings of England to be arrested and charged with the crime of treason? It seems that there was reason enough for Clarence to be incarcerated in the Tower of London and charged. There can be no doubt that George was in trouble. 

​The Crowland Chronicles suggest that the ill feeling had been brewing between the brothers for some time and in a superstitious age, Edward may have been concerned with the prophecy that someone whose name began with the letter G would take his kingdom from him. Most certainly Edward was building up some sort of list of information to be used against his brother, and this prophecy added weight to his theory that George had his eye on his throne. But what about Richard, a future king of England. Was he whispering in the king's ear about Clarence as some historians suggest?

Naturally, Shakespeare has Richard playing his part in Clarence's downfall but surprisingly the 'expert' on the subject of Richard III, Sir Thomas More, is doubtful of Richards's guilt even Shakespeare's 'biggest fan' the nineteenth-century historian James Gairdner, doesn't think he was guilty either, he writes 

" he (Richard) was lukewarm in his opposition and should be considered guiltless of his brothers death"

 But according to Professor Michael Hicks, George's conviction was a 

" Precondition for Gloucester's accession in 1483" 

So George was accused of rebellion, slander and allegiances with the 'enemy' and the date set for the trial was probably around 20th January. The king was said to have attended stating that his brother was

'guilty of unnatural, loathly treasons' 

The act regarding these charges is still in existence. Within the Crowland Chronicle it is written

 "no one spoke against the duke but the king, and no one answered but the duke" 

Towards the end of the trial, in a desperate attempt at a chance of coming out of this affair with his life, Clarence offers to prove his innocence in personal combat, but in the end, a guilty verdict was read out by the Duke of Buckingham and George, Duke of Clarence, had to wait just under a month for his execution.

There is no evidence of how Clarence met his end, but the barrel of wine story persists as these things do. 

As proof that drowning was the manner of George's death the painting below has been cited. Clarence's daughter Margaret Pole wears a tiny barrel charm on a bracelet which is taken to represent her father's death! Of course, this is the usual case of fabricating the evidence to fit the crime. Not only did this one tiny detail added weight to the vat of wine theory but it meant that this portrait has been wrongly attributed.
Picture
This art work was painted in 1535, the sitter unknown.
Clarence's execution took place in private, and it is commonly thought that he went to a death of his own choosing, probably beheading. But those who believe that the remains (a body with the head intact) that lies at Tewkesbury Abbey is George Duke of Clarence would disagree. ​
​
Picture
Death of Clarence - Illustration by Alice Povey
So, who do I think was responsible for Clarence's death? 

Probably Edward. Maybe Richard. But ultimately it was George himself. He was his own worst enemy.
​
*John Ashdown Hills biography on the Duke of Clarence is available here
 http://www.johnashdownhill.com/the-third-plantagenet-george-duke-of-clarence/
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    1420
    1450
    1461
    1471
    14th Century
    15th Century
    16th Century
    19th Century
    Acts Statutes And Treaties
    Adam Moleyns
    Alice De La Pole
    Alice Montacute
    Andrew Trollope
    Anjou
    Anne Beauchamp
    Anne Mortimer
    Anne Neville
    Anthony Woodville
    April
    Aristrocracy And Nobility
    Art
    Audley Family
    August
    Baron Sutton
    Battle Of Barnet
    Battle Of Blore Heath
    Battle Of Bosworth
    Battle Of Bramham Moor
    Battle Of Edgecote
    Battle Of Edington
    Battle Of Ferrybridge
    Battle Of Hedgeley Moor
    Battle Of Losecoat Field
    Battle Of Ludford Bridge
    Battle Of Mortimer's Cross
    Battle Of Shewsbury
    Battle Of St Albans 1455
    Battle Of St Albans 1461
    Battle Of Stoke
    Battle Of Tewkesbury
    Battle Of Towton
    Battle Of Wakefield
    Beaumont Family
    Berwick On Tweed
    Boston
    Bosworth Field
    Bredwardine Family
    Burgundian Wars
    Cadaver Tomb
    Calais
    Castles
    Cathedrals And Churches
    Catherine Of Valois
    Cecily Neville
    Charles The Bold
    Christmas
    Crowland Abbey
    Crowland Cronicles
    December
    De La Pole Family
    Despencer Family
    De Vere Family
    Dublin
    Duchess Of Burgundy
    Duchess Of Suffolk
    Duke Of York
    Earl Of Devon
    Earl Of Salisbury
    Edmund Beaufort Duke Of Somerset
    Edmund Earl Of Rutland
    Edmund Tudor
    Edward Earl Of Warwick
    Edward III
    Edward IV
    Edward Of Lancaster
    Edward Of Middleham
    Edward The Black Prince
    Edward V
    Elizabeth
    Elizabeth I
    Elizabeth Of York
    Elizabeth Woodville
    Execution Of Nobles
    February
    Food
    France
    Francis Lovell
    Gainsborough Hall
    Geoffrey Chaucer
    George Duke Of Clarence
    God
    Hampshire
    Henry Earl Of Lancester
    Henry Percy
    Henry Tudor
    Henry V
    Henry VI
    Henry VII
    Henry VIII
    Hereford
    Humphrey Duke Of Gloucester
    Humphrey Stafford
    Isabella Of Burgundy
    Isabel Neville
    Isabel Of Bourbon
    Jack Cade
    James I Of England
    James Tuchet
    January
    Jasper Tudor
    John Beaufort
    John Clifford
    John De La Pole
    John De Vere
    John Duke Of Bedford
    John Fiennes
    John Grey Of Groby
    John Leland
    John Morton
    John Of Gaunt
    John Sutton
    John Tuchet
    July
    June
    Katherine (daug Of Richard III)
    Lambart Simnel
    Lancaster
    Leicester
    Lincolnshire
    Lionel Of Antwerp
    Literature
    Lord Audley
    Louis XI
    Ludlow
    March
    Margaret Beauchamp
    Margaret Beaufort
    Margaret Of Anjou
    Margaret Of York
    Mary Of Guelders
    Mary Of Guise
    May
    Medicine
    Medieval Castles
    Medieval Music
    Medieval Warfare
    Micklegate Bar
    Mohun Family
    Mortimer Cross
    Neville Family
    Normandy
    Northamptonshire
    Nostell Priory
    Nottinghamshire
    November
    October
    On This Day
    Owen Glyndwr
    Owen Tudor
    Parhelion
    Parliament
    Percy Family
    Philippe De Commynes
    Phillippe Pot
    Plantagenet
    Pontifract
    Prince Of Wales
    Princes
    Princes In The Tower
    Princesses
    Propaganda
    Ralph And Edward Shaa
    Ravenspur
    Readeption Of Henry VI
    Rebellion
    Re Enactments
    Revenge
    Rhys Ap Thomas
    Richard Duke Of York
    Richard Herbert
    Richard II
    Richard III
    Richard Neville
    Richard Neville (The King Maker)
    Richard Of Conisbrough
    Richard Of Eastwell
    Richard Of Shrewsbury
    Road To Bosworth: Henry Of Richmond
    Robin Of Redesdale
    Roger Vaughan
    Rowland Lockey
    Rutland
    Sandal Castle
    Sand Sculptures
    Saxton
    Scarborough
    Second Battle Of St Albans
    September
    Shakespeare
    Skirbeck
    Statutes And Treaties
    St Paul's Cross London
    Sufflok
    Tattershall
    Tattershall Collage
    Tewkesbury Abbey
    The Arrivall
    The Beaufort Family
    The Black Death
    The Black Prince
    The Blue Boar Inn
    The Browne Family
    The De La Pole Family
    The Hollow Crown
    The King Maker
    The Legendary Ten Seconds
    The-road-to-bosworth-richard-iii
    The-road-to-bosworth-richard-iii
    The Tudors
    The Wakefield Tower
    The Woodville Family
    Thomas Browne
    Thomas Burgh
    Thomas Clifford
    Thomas Earl Of Lancaster
    Thomas More
    Thomas Percy
    Thomas Stanley
    Thomas Vaughan
    Tilney Family
    Tower Of London
    Towton 25
    Transie Tomb
    Treaties
    Tudor
    Tudors
    Tyrell Family
    Vengeance
    Vulgate
    Wales
    Walter Devereux
    Wars Of The Roses
    Wars Of The Roses In Art
    Weapons
    Welles Family
    Westminster Abbey
    William Aschough
    William Cromer
    William De La Pole
    William Hastings
    William Herbert
    William Hobbes
    William Of Hatfield
    William Of Worcester
    William Oldhall
    William Shakespeare
    Women
    Woodville Family
    York
    Yorkshire

    Archives

    December 2022
    September 2022
    June 2022
    November 2021
    January 2021
    September 2020
    July 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    December 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.