Meandering Through Time
  • Home
  • The Ancestors
  • Family Stories
    • Bustaine of Braunton: Introduction
    • Hendley of Coursehorne Kent >
      • Gervais Hendley >
        • Other Hendleys >
          • Hendley Family Tree
    • Hunt of Barnstaple Introduction >
      • Christopher Hunt
      • Edward Hunt
      • Richard Hunt
      • Richard Hunt
      • Mary Hunt
    • Lakeman of Mevagissey >
      • Peter Lakeman c1698-1740
    • Meavy Introduction >
      • 6th to 9th Century Meavy >
        • Meavy Pre Conquest >
          • 1066 and Life in Domesday England >
            • Domesday and 13th Century Charters >
              • The Anarchy >
                • Walter, Wido and William Meavy >
                  • The Beginnings of a New Era
    • Mitchell of Crantock: An Introduction >
      • William Mitchell of Crantock >
        • Samuel Mitchell of Crantock >
          • Edith Mitchell >
            • Epilogue: Lescliston Farm
    • Mohun of Dunster: Introduction >
      • William Mohun c1050 - c1111 >
        • William Mohun c1100 - c1143 >
          • William Mohun - 1176 >
            • William - 1193 >
              • Reynold Mohun c1183 - 1213
              • Reynold Mohun c1210 -1257 >
                • Alice Mohun
    • Scoboryo of St Columb Major >
      • James and Joan Scoboryo 1640 - 1686
    • Thomas Vaughan: An Introduction >
      • Chapter One: Monmouthshire, Wales.
      • Chapter Two: The Beaufort Patronage
      • ​Chapter Three: Out With the Old
      • Chapter Four: Kentish Connections and Opportunities >
        • Chapter Five: Getting Personal
        • Chapter Six: ​The Children of Thomas Vaughan
        • Chapter Seven: Moving on
        • ​Chapter Eight: At Ludlow
        • Chapter Nine: The Arrest
        • Chapter Ten: Three Castles
        • Chapter Eleven: The Beginning of the End
        • Chapter Twelve: A Death Deserved ?
    • Smith of Barkby Introduction >
      • Susanna Smith
    • Taylor Introduction >
      • Joseph Taylor >
        • John Henry Taylor
    • Tosny of Normandy >
      • Godehute de Tosny
    • Toon of Leicestershire: Introduction >
      • John Toon 1799 -
      • Thomas Toon 1827 - 1874
    • Underwood of Coleorton Introduction
  • History Blog
  • Wars of the Roses Blog
  • History Bites
  • Out and About
  • A to E
  • F to J
  • K to O
  • P to T
  • U to Z
  • Links
  • Contact
  • New Page

Feudalism and Chivalry: Fact or Fiction?

17/5/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
When we see images of angry, missile throwing rioters, and the masses out of control or groups of people shouting abuse at one another we use the terms 'positively medieval' or 'how feudal'. When someone, usually a male, performs a kind deed we remark 'how chivalrous.'  

We know these terms come from our own history but were the ideals they are based on real?

Not too long ago I sat down to watch The Lion in Winter, one of my all time favourite films. I have two reasons for seeing it as  a good film, firstly, because it depicts the medieval period, in this case the court of Henry II, as I believe it was, cold, cruel and barbaric and secondly, the characters portray none of the chivalric behaviour that people of these times thought so very highly of. What we see is an unstable King Henry II, who bellows and bullies his way through the film, whilst his sons are petulant and violent, this is representative of the medieval era and the medieval ruling classes, and how, on the whole, we should see them. There were no glamorous, young and impulsive warriors adorned in shining armour, seeing off fire breathing dragons or saving beautiful damsels, there were only experienced, battle hardened men living in a world of politics, who controlled the country through what has come to be known as feudalism.
Picture
The feudal system, as explained to us in school, was a system of government, organised by rank with a set of rules agreed between them that we associate with the middle ages. Medieval people did not talk of a feudal system, in fact the term 'feudal' was used only as far back as the eighteenth century in reference to out of date and unfair laws. The system I learnt at school was a system where the king ruled and protected his country, his barons supplied the knights for the army in times of war and the peasants did all the rest. 


Twenty years after conquering our country the king commissioned the Domesday Book where he set out to find what and how much each county had in terms of land and stock, and once it was finished it formed the basic structure of feudalism. The king had no restrictions on his power, he confiscated all the English lands, worked out how very wealthy he was, shared out these lands among his loyal band of followers and expected a declaration of loyalty from everyone in return.

 In theory, to him at least, it was a perfect system. 
Picture
Chivalry was not an actual practice but an ideal, maybe we should view feudalism in the same vain, just a way of explaining the workings of government in a complicated political age in a country managed by hereditary rulers. 

So was it a set of rules laid down or was it just a pattern of behaviour between the weak and the strong? 

Were the Normans the first to put this concept into place or did it begin in an earlier, even more barbaric era, a time when life for most was abysmal, where people lived in such terror that they were prepared to pay to be protected or maybe it was the other way round, where weak tribal leaders and later as we've seen with kings, brought support by giving their nobles the opportunity to be land holders themselves.

 It is here, among the newly landed medieval knightly class that chivalry was born and chivalric values come into play. The code of chivalry is described in the Song of Roland, a poem based on a battle that took place in the year 778 where it talks of a code of conduct a medieval knight must abide by.

                                                                         To fear God and maintain his Church
                                                                      To serve the leige lord in valour and faith
                                                                         To protect the weak and defenceless
                                                                              To live by honour and for glory
                                                                                To fight for the welfare of all
                                                                            To obey those placed in authority
                                                                         To guard the honour of fellow knights
                                                                             To respect the honour of women
​

Picture
 I have no doubt that men, thrown together in times of war, would expect honor and courage and respect and loyalty, but where were these heroic set of values when they changed allegiances, rebelled against their king and slaughtered hundreds of peasants? 

Chivalry, in reality is a myth, the idealised image we have in our heads was created for us in the tales of Walter Scott, the poems of Tennyson and the images of Bauer, Waterhouse and Leighton and as far as feudalism goes medieval historians are now arguing that there was no such thing as a feudal system at all and suggest that chivalry was just simple propaganda by the knightly class who needed to be seen as heroes in the face of the poor who complained of bullying and a life of subjugation.
0 Comments
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    February 2014
    November 2013
    September 2013
    March 2013

    Categories

    All
    10th Century
    11th Century
    12th Century
    13th Century
    14th Century
    15th Century
    16th Century
    17th Century
    18th Century
    19th Century
    20th Century
    5th Century
    6th Century
    7th Century
    8th Century
    9th Century
    Academia
    Adeliza Of Louvain
    Aethelred
    Agincourt
    Alexander III Of Scotland
    Alexander The Great
    Alice In Wonderland
    Alice Lisle
    Ambrose Rookwoode
    America
    Amy Licence
    Amy Robsart
    Angelica Kauffman
    Angevin Dynasty
    Anglo Saxon
    Anne Askew
    Anne Boleyn
    Anne Neville
    Anne Of Cleves
    Anne Seymour Darmer
    Anthony Browne
    Appledore
    April
    Archbishop Of Canterbury
    Archibald Douglas
    Armour And Weapons
    Art
    Arthur Prince Of Wales
    Artists
    Audley
    Audley Family
    August
    Babington Plot
    Bardney Abbey
    Barons War
    Battle Of Bosworth
    Battle Of Bramham Moor
    Battle Of Buranburh
    Battle Of Castillon
    Battle Of Crecy
    Battle Of Deptford Bridge
    Battle Of Dyrham
    Battle Of Edington
    Battle Of Evesham
    Battle Of Flodden
    Battle Of Fulford
    Battle Of Hastings
    Battle Of Leipzig
    Battle Of Lewes
    Battle Of Lincoln
    Battle Of Maserfield
    Battle Of Northam
    Battle Of Radcot Bridge
    Battle Of Sedgemoor
    Battle Of Shrewsbury
    Battle Of Stamford Bridge
    Battle Of Stirling Bridge
    Battle Of Torrington
    Battle Of Towton
    Battle Of Trafalgar
    Battle Of Visby
    Battle Of Worchester
    Batttle Of Tettenhall
    Beards
    Beatrice De Say
    Beauchamp Family
    Beaufort Family
    Berkshire
    Bess Of Hardwick
    Bevill Grenville
    Binamy Castle
    Bishop Robert Grosseteste
    Bite Sized History
    Blackbeard
    Black Death
    Blackheath
    Blanche Of Artois
    Blanche Of Lancaster
    Blanchminster
    Boleyn Family
    Bolingbroke Castle
    Books
    Boston
    Boudica
    Bridgnorth Castle
    Burgundy
    Burial Practices
    Bury St Edmunds
    Byard The Horse
    Cardinal Wolsey
    Carey Family
    Caroline Von Schoenberg
    Castle Drogo
    Castles
    Cathedrals
    Catherine Grey
    Catherine Howard
    Catherine Of Aragon
    Catherine Of Valois
    Catherine Of York
    Catherine Parr
    Catholic/Protestant Troubles
    Cecily Neville
    Celts
    Chapel Of St Peter Ad Vincula
    Charlemagne
    Charles Dickens
    Charles I
    Charles II
    Charles Landseer
    Charles VI Of France
    Chaucer
    Childbirth
    Children Of Henry II
    Children's History
    Chivalry
    Christopher Marlowe
    City Of London
    Civil War
    Civil Wars
    Colins De Beaumont
    Collegiate Church
    Colonel Blood
    Combat
    Conservation
    Cornish
    Cornish Cream Teas
    Cornish Hedges
    Cornish Rebellion
    Cornish Saints
    Cornishware
    Cornwall
    Coronation Of Monarchs
    Cotehele
    Countess Of Salisbury
    Count Of Perche.
    Courtly Love
    Cowdray Park
    Craft
    Crantock
    Crime And Punishment
    Cronin
    Crowland Abbey
    Crowland Chronicles
    Crown Jewels
    Crusades
    Dam Busters
    David Of Scotland
    De Burgh Family
    December
    De Clare Family
    De La Pole Family
    De Tracy Of Devon
    Devon
    Dick Turpin
    Dolly Pentreath
    Dragons
    Duchy Of Cornwall
    Dudley Family
    Duke Of Buckingham
    Duke Of Cornwall
    Duke Of Norfolk
    Duke Of Wellington
    Eadred
    Earl Ferrers
    Earl Of Southampton
    Earls Of Cornwall
    Edgar Aetheling
    Edgar Allen Poe
    Edmund Crouchback
    Edmund Ironside
    Edmund (Saxon King)
    Edmund Tudor
    Edward Clinton
    Edward Courtenay
    Edward I
    Edward II
    Edward III
    Edward IV
    Edward Montague
    Edward Seymour
    Edward Stafford
    Edward The Black Prince
    Edward The Confessor
    Edward VI
    Edward VII
    Edward VIII
    Edwin Aethling
    Eleanor Of Aquitaine
    Eleanor Of Castile
    Eleanor Of Lancaster
    Eleanor Of Provence
    Elizabethan Playwrights
    Elizabeth Barton
    Elizabeth Browne
    Elizabeth Fitzgerald
    Elizabeth I
    Elizabeth II
    Elizabeth Of York
    Elizabeth Stuart
    Elizabeth Throckmorton
    Empress Matilda
    English Civil War
    English Saints
    English Villages
    Ethel Rudkin
    Executions Of Nobles
    Family History
    Fashion
    February
    Feudalism
    Finn Mc Cool
    Fitzalan Family
    Fitz Peirs Family
    Fletcher Christian
    Folk Tales And Legends
    Fotheringhay Castle
    France
    Frances I
    Francis Bacon
    Francis Brandon
    Francis Drake
    Francis Grey
    Francis Treshem
    Fredrick Barbarossa
    French Revolution
    Galileo
    Genealogy
    General Gordon Of Khartoum
    Geoffrey Boleyn
    Geoffrey Of Monmouth
    Geoffrey Pole
    George And The Dragon
    George Boleyn
    George Duke Of Clarence
    George III
    George Neville
    George Orwell
    George Talbot
    Geraldine Family
    Gildas
    Giuseppe Balsamo
    Glouchestershire
    Gothic
    Gotland
    Great Fire Of London
    Great War
    Grimesthorpe House
    Guildford Dudley
    Guildhalls
    Gunpowder Plot
    Gurturde Blount
    Guthrum
    Guy De Beauchamp
    Guy Fawkes
    Halloween
    Hampton Court
    Hans Holbein
    Harald Hardrada
    Harold Godwinson
    Harold Hardrada
    H Bomb Tests
    Helhiem
    Henry Beaumont
    Henry Bolingbroke (Henry IV)
    Henry Brooke (Lord Cobham)
    Henry Grey Duke Of Suffolk
    Henry Howard
    Henry I
    Henry II
    Henry III
    Henry IV
    Henry IV Of France
    Henry Of Grosmont
    Henry Of Lancaster
    Henry Percy
    Henry Pole
    Henry Stuary
    Henry-stuary-lord-darnley
    Henry The Young King
    Henry V
    Henry VI
    Henry VII
    Henry VIII
    Herbs
    Heritage Crimes
    Hieronymus Bosch
    Historical Films
    History Bites
    Homers IIiad
    Horatio Nelson
    House Of York
    Humphrey Duke Of Gloucester
    Humphry Davy
    Huntspill
    Iceni
    Independence
    Industral Revolution
    Industrial Revolution
    Influenza
    Inventions
    Ireland
    Isabella Of Angouleme
    Isabella Of Baveria
    Isabella Of France
    Isabella Of Portugal
    Isambard Kingdom Brunel
    Jack Leslau
    Jacques De Molay
    James Bothwell
    James I
    James IV Of Scotland
    James V
    James Watt
    Jane Boleyn
    Jane Parker Lady Rochford
    January
    Joan Of Arc
    Joan Of Kent
    Joan Of The Tower
    Joan Vaux
    John Bampton
    John Cabot
    John Chandos
    John Churchill
    John Clifford
    John De Warenne
    John Dudley Duke Of Northumberland
    John Eliot
    John Fisher
    John Hussey
    John Montague
    John Of Eltham
    John Of Gaunt
    John Of Portugal
    John Stewart Duke Of Albany
    John Sutton
    John Talbot
    John Talbot (1453)
    John Wesley
    John Wilkes
    John Wingfield
    Judge Jeffreys
    Julius Ceasar
    Julius Drewe
    July
    June
    June 21st
    King Alfred The Great
    King Arthur
    King Athelstan
    King Cnut
    King Harold
    King John
    King Johns Treasure
    King Stephen
    Kirkby Muxloe
    Knights
    Lace Making
    Lady D'Abanville
    Lady Godiva
    Lady Jane Grey
    Laurence Olivier
    Law And Order
    Leicester
    Leicestershire
    Leofric
    Lewis Carroll
    Lincoln Castle
    Lincoln Cathedral
    Lincolnshire
    Lionel Of Antwerp
    Lion In Winter
    Livinia Fontana
    Loki
    London
    Lord Darnley
    Lord Monteagle
    Lords Appellant
    Louis II Of France
    Louis VIII Of France
    Louis VII Of France
    Louis XI Of France
    Louis XVI Of France
    Love
    Ludlow Castle
    Maleficent
    March
    Margaret Cameron
    Margaret Of England
    Margaret Pole
    Margaret Roper
    Margaret Tudor
    Marie Antoinette
    Marie Lloyd
    Martin Luther
    Mary I
    Mary Of Guise
    Mary Queen Of Scots
    Mary Tudor
    Mathew Paris
    Matilda
    Matilda Of Scotland
    Matthew Parker
    Maud Of Lancaster
    May
    Mayflower
    Medieval
    Medieval Christmas
    Medieval Music
    Medieval Warfare
    Medieval Women
    Michael Joseph An Gof
    Midwives
    Mini History Blog
    Mining
    Mohun Family
    Mohun Of Dunster
    Monmouth Rebellion
    Muntiny On The Bounty
    Music Hall
    Mutiny On The Bounty
    Myths And Legends
    Myths Superstition And Legends
    Napoleon
    National Trust
    Newark Castle
    Newquay
    Nobility
    Normandy
    Norman Lords
    Norse Mythology
    Northumberland
    November
    October
    Of Cornwall
    Oliver Cromwell
    On This Day
    Operation Grapple
    Owen Tudor
    Oxfordshire
    Pagans
    Paul Delarouche
    Peasants Revolt
    Peeping Tom
    Peter The Great
    Pevensey Bay
    Philip Larkin
    Philippa Gregory
    Philippa Of Hainault
    Phillip The Good
    Piers Gaveston
    Pilgrimage Of Grace
    Pirates
    Plague And Pestilence
    Plantagnet
    Plymouth
    Poetry
    Pole Family
    Pontifract Castle
    Prince Charles
    Prince Of Wales
    Princes In The Tower
    Queen Anne
    Queen Victoria
    Ralph De Coggeshall
    Ralph Hopton
    Ranulf Flambard
    Reading Abbey
    Reginald Pole
    Reign Of Elizabeth I
    Rhys Ap Thomas
    Richard Carew
    Richard Duke Of York
    Richard Earl Of Cornwall
    Richard Empson
    Richard Fitz Alan
    Richard I
    Richard II
    Richard III
    Richard Trevithick
    RIII Visitors Centre
    Riot Act
    Riots And Civil Disobedience
    River Tamar
    Rober Cecil
    Robert Beauchamp
    Robert Cecil
    Robert Count Of Mortain
    Robert De Boron
    Robert Deveraux
    Robert De Vere
    Robert Dudley
    Robert Earl Of Gloucester
    Robert Of Gloucester
    Robert Stephen Hawker
    Robert The Bruce
    Robert Tresillian
    Robin Hood
    Roger Mortimer
    Roger Of Wendover
    Roman/Greek Gods
    Romans
    Royal Air Force
    Saints
    Saints Day
    Salam Witch Trials
    Samuel Foote
    Samuel Pepys
    Sarah Churchill
    Science
    Science And Technology
    Scoboryo Family
    Scotland
    Scottish Kings
    Sculpture
    Seagull
    Second Barons War
    September
    Settlements And Contracts
    Shakespeare
    Sheffield Cathedral
    Sheriff Of Nottingham
    Shewsbury Castle
    Shropshire
    Simon De Montfort
    Simon Of Sudbury
    Sir Francis Drake
    Sir Ralph Hopton
    Sir Walter Raleigh
    Slums
    Snow White
    Somerset
    Song Of Roland
    Spain
    Spanish Armada
    Stannaries
    Statute Of Marlborough
    Statute Of Rhuddlan
    St Columb
    St Columb Major
    St Edmund
    St George
    St Mawgan
    Stonehenge
    St Oswald
    Stratton
    Sudeley Castle
    Sweden
    Sweyn Forkbeard
    Symbolism
    Talbot Family
    Tattershall
    Tattershall Castle
    Templar Knights
    Tewkesbury Abbey
    The Anarchy
    The Arts
    The Arundel Family
    The Ashburnham Family
    The Beauchamp Family
    The Beaufort Family
    The Beaumont Family
    The Bloody Assizes
    The Bonython Family
    The Civil War
    The Courtenay Family
    The Crusades
    The D'Aincourt Family
    The De Montfort Family
    The Despencer Family
    The De Tosny Family
    The De Vere Family
    The Dudley Family
    The Grey Family
    The Gunpowder Plot
    The Hollow Crown
    The Hundred Years War
    The Mortimer Family
    The Peasants Revolt
    The Percy Family Of Alnwick
    The Raven
    The Rough Wooing
    The Seymour Family
    The Sutton Family
    The Talbot Family
    The Taylor Family
    The Tilbury Speech
    The West Country
    The White Ship Disaster
    The Year: 1381
    Thomas Becket
    Thomas Boleyn
    Thomas Cranmer
    Thomas Cromwell
    Thomas Culpepper
    Thomas Darcy
    Thomas Fairfax
    Thomas Flamank
    Thomas Herriot
    Thomas Holland
    Thomasine Blight
    Thomas More
    Thomas Mowbray
    Thomas Of Lancaster
    Thomas Percy
    Thomas Seymour
    Thomas Walsingham
    Thomas Wriothesley
    Thomas Wyatt
    Tin Mining
    Tintagel Castle
    Tostig Godwinson
    Tournaments
    Tower Of London
    Towton
    Treason And Plot
    Treaties
    Tristran And Isolde
    Tudor Period
    Tudors
    Tyrwhitt
    Ufford Family
    Usurption
    Uta Of Naumburg
    Valdemar Of Denmark
    Valentines Day
    Vallatort Family
    Vaux Passional
    Vengence
    Victorian Paintings
    Vikings
    Viscount Lisle
    Wales
    Wallis Simpson
    Walter Raleigh
    Walter Scott
    Waltheof Earl Of Northumberland
    War Ships
    Wars Of The Roses
    Wat Tyler
    Welsh Castles
    West Country
    Westminster Abbey
    Whitchurch
    White Horse
    Wildlife
    William Adelin
    William Bligh
    William Cecil
    William Davidson
    William De Mandeville
    William De Wrotham
    William Henry Fox Talbot
    William Marshall
    William Montague
    William Moray
    William Paget
    William Parker 11th Baron Monteagle
    William Roper
    William Rufus
    William Shakespeare
    William The Conqueror
    William Wallace
    William Waller
    Willoughby Family
    Wiltishire
    Wiltshire
    Winchester Castle
    Winchester Cathedral
    Winter Solstice
    Witch
    Wolf Hall
    Women
    Women Studies
    World War I
    Writers
    York
    Yorkshire


    After ten years in the workplace I became a mother to three very beautiful daughters, I was fortunate enough to have been able to stay at home and spend my time with them as they grew into the young women they are now. I am still in the position of being able to be at home and pursue all the interests I have previously mentioned. We live in a beautiful Victorian spa town with wooded walks for the dog, lovely shops and a host of lovely people, what more could I ask for.

    All works © Andrea Povey 2014. Please do not reproduce without the expressed written consent of Andrea Povey.

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.